(updated 05/05/2005)
Is retention over time affected differently by test vs. study?
Task:
Learn 60 obscure facts à test or re-study opportunity à test retention at 5 min, 1 day, 2 days, 7 days, 14 days, and 42 days.
Stimuli:
Item
|
Fact |
Question |
Answer |
1 |
The first calculator, the abacus, came from China. |
What is the name of the first calculator, which came from
China? |
abacus |
2 |
Ceres was the Roman goddess of agriculture. |
Ceres was the Roman goddess of what? |
agriculture |
3 |
The word "amateur" was eliminated from the
Olympic Charter. |
What word was eliminated from the Olympic Charter? |
amateur |
4 |
The amethyst was Cleopatra's signet. |
What gem was Cleopatra's signet? |
amethyst |
5 |
Charlie Brown's father was a barber. |
What profession was Charlie Brown's father? |
barber |
6 |
A Bathometer is used to measure sea depth under a moving
vessel. |
What is used for measuring sea depth under a moving
vessel? |
bathometer |
7 |
The background house in the painting "American
Gothic" is a brothel. |
What is the background house in the painting
"American Gothic?" |
brothel |
8 |
Buddha is said to have found enlightenment while sitting
under a tree. |
Who is said to have found enlightenment while sitting
under a tree? |
Buddha |
9 |
Prior to the bulldog, Yale's mascot was a cat |
What was Yale's mascot prior to the bulldog? |
cat |
10 |
Knute Rockne taught chemistry at Notre Dame before
coaching football. |
What did Knute Rockne teach at Notre Dame before coaching
football? |
Chemistry |
11 |
Booker T. Washington was the first African-American to
appear on a coin. |
Booker T. Washington was the first African-American to
appear on what? |
coin |
12 |
Donuts were the only product promoted by Elvis Presley in
a TV commercial. |
What was the only product promoted by Elvis Presley in a
TV commercial? |
donuts |
13 |
The Mercalli scale is used to measure damage caused by an
earthquake. |
The Mercalli scale is used to measure damage caused by
what? |
earthquake |
14 |
Benjamin Harrison was president when electricity was
brought to the White House. |
What was brought to the White House when Benjamin Harris
was president? |
electricity |
15 |
In mythology, Prometheus stole fire from the gods. |
In mythology, what did Prometheus steal from the gods? |
fire |
16 |
The name of TV detective Baretta's pet cockatoo was Fred. |
What was the name of TV detective Baretta's pet cockatoo? |
Fred |
17 |
The giraffe was once called a camelopard. |
What animal was once called a camelopard? |
giraffe |
18 |
The national flower of the United States is the Goldenrod. |
What is the national flower of the United States? |
Goldenrod |
19 |
Greyhounds have the best eyesight of any dog. |
What breed of dog has the best eyesight? |
greyhound |
20 |
The first drive-in service station in the U.S. was Gulf. |
What was the first drive-in service station in the U.S? |
Gulf |
21 |
Moscow's largest department store is named GUM. |
What is the name of Moscow's largest deparment store? |
GUM |
22 |
A "hamlet" is a group of houses smaller than a
village. |
What term refers to a group of houses smaller than a
village? |
hamlet |
23 |
The hippo has killed more people than any other African
animal. |
What has killed more people than any other African animal?
|
hippo |
24 |
“Houston” was the working title of the TV series
"Dallas.” |
What was the working title of the TV series
"Dallas"? |
Houston |
25 |
Christopher Cockerell invented the hovercraft. |
What did Christopher Cockerell invent? |
hovercraft |
26 |
Hydrogen is the most common element in the universe. |
What is the most common element in the universe? |
hydrogen |
27 |
Hypnotism was pioneered by the Austrian physician Dr.
Mesmer |
What was pioneered by the Austrian physician Dr. Mesmer? |
hypnotism |
28 |
The word "bandit" comes from the Italian
language. |
What language does the word "bandit" come from? |
Italian |
29 |
"Jack" is the most commonly-used name in nursery
rhymes. |
What is the most commonly-used name in nursery rhymes? |
Jack |
30 |
The Egyptian god Anubis has the body of a man and the head
of a jackal. |
The Egyptian god Anibus has the head of what animal? |
jackal |
31 |
Francis Scott Key's profession was a lawyer. |
What was Francis Scott Key's profession? |
lawyer |
32 |
A lion is the animal that appears on the flag of Sri
Lanka. |
What animal appears on the flag of Sri Lanka? |
lion |
33 |
Michigan is the inland state with the longest shoreline. |
What inland state has the longest shoreline? |
Michigan |
34 |
The state flower of Rhode Island is mistletoe. |
What is the state flower of Rhode Island? |
mistletoe |
35 |
Selenology is the study of the moon. |
What is studied in selenology? |
moon |
36 |
Muhammed is the most popular name in the world. |
What is the most popular name in the world? |
Muhammed |
37 |
The Secret Service code name for Frank Sinatra was
Napoleon. |
What was the Secret Service code name for Frank Sinatra? |
Napoleon |
38 |
The Netherlands was ruled by female monarchs during the
20th century. |
What country was ruled by female monarchs during the 20th
century? |
Netherlands |
39 |
The term "laundry bag" means parachute in Army
slang. |
What does the term "laundry bag" mean in Army
slang? |
parachute |
40 |
Fake pearls were once made out of fish scales. |
What type of fake jewelry was once made out of fish
scales? |
pearls |
41 |
Pitch was used to seal the basket that carried baby Moses.
|
What was used to seal the basket that carried baby Moses? |
pitch |
42 |
A plexor is the hammer doctors use to test patients'
reflexes. |
What is the hammer doctors use to test patients' reflexes? |
plexor |
43 |
Nicholas Breakspear was the only Englishman to become
Pope. |
Nicholas Breakspear was the only Englishman to become
what? |
Pope |
44 |
In a church, a "galilee" refers to a porch. |
In a church, what is a "galilee?" |
porch |
45 |
Louis Pasteur developed a vaccine for rabies. |
Louis Pasteur developed a vaccine for what condition? |
rabies |
46 |
Disney’s dog Pluto was originally called
"Rover." |
Disney’s dog Pluto was originally called what? |
Rover |
47 |
The septum is the body part that separates the nostrils. |
What is the body part that separates the nostrils? |
septum |
48 |
The word "set" has more definitions than any
other English word. |
What word has more definitions than any other English
word? |
set |
49 |
An earthworm perceives light through its skin. |
Through what organ does an earthworm perceive light? |
skin |
50 |
The game of softball was originally called kitten ball. |
What game was originally called kitten ball? |
softball |
51 |
Studebaker produced a car called the Dictator. |
What car company produced a car called the Dictator? |
Studebaker |
52 |
The Swedish version of the Easter Bunny is the Easter
Cuckoo. |
The Easter Cuckoo is what country' s version of the Easter
Bunny? |
Sweden |
53 |
The dot over the letter 'i' is called a tittle. |
What is the dot over the letter "i" called? |
tittle |
54 |
Jules Leotard introduced the trapeze. |
What was introduced by Jules Leotard? |
trapeze |
55 |
Venus is the only planet in our solar system that rotates
clockwise. |
What is the only planet in our solar system that rotates
clockwise? |
Venus |
56 |
Leonardo da Vinci was born in Vinci. |
In what village was Leonardo da Vinci born? |
Vinci |
57 |
"Water" was the first word "spoken" by
Helen Keller. |
What was the first word "spoken" by Helen Keller |
water |
58 |
The wrinkled flesh on the neck of a turkey is called a
wattle. |
What is the wrinkled flesh on the neck of a turkey called? |
wattle |
59 |
King George VI competed at Wimbledon. |
King George VI competed at what professional competition? |
Wimbledon |
60 |
Zorro's real name is Don Diego de la Vega. |
What character's real name is Don Diego de la Vega? |
Zorro |
Design:
2 within-subjects trial conditions:
1. Test: fact presented as question à subject covertly recalls one-word answer + feedback
2. Study: fact presented as question and one-word answer provided
6 within-subjects RI conditions:
1. 5 min
2. 1 day
3. 2 days
4. 7 days
5. 14 days
6. 42 days
Items will be randomly assigned to conditions for each subject (5 items per condition):
Item # |
Trial Condition |
RI Condition |
1 |
Test |
5 min |
2 |
Test |
1 day |
3 |
Test |
2 days |
4 |
Test |
7 days |
5 |
Test |
14 days |
6 |
Test |
42 days |
7 |
Test |
5 min |
8 |
Test |
1 day |
9 |
Test |
2 days |
10 |
Test |
7 days |
11 |
Test |
14 days |
12 |
Test |
42 days |
13 |
Test |
5 min |
14 |
Test |
1 day |
15 |
Test |
2 days |
16 |
Test |
7 days |
17 |
Test |
14 days |
18 |
Test |
42 days |
19 |
Test |
5 min |
20 |
Test |
1 day |
21 |
Test |
2 days |
22 |
Test |
7 days |
23 |
Test |
14 days |
24 |
Test |
42 days |
25 |
Test |
5 min |
26 |
Test |
1 day |
27 |
Test |
2 days |
28 |
Test |
7 days |
29 |
Test |
14 days |
30 |
Test |
42 days |
31 |
Study |
5 min |
32 |
Study |
1 day |
33 |
Study |
2 days |
34 |
Study |
7 days |
35 |
Study |
14 days |
36 |
Study |
42 days |
37 |
Study |
5 min |
38 |
Study |
1 day |
39 |
Study |
2 days |
40 |
Study |
7 days |
41 |
Study |
14 days |
42 |
Study |
42 days |
43 |
Study |
5 min |
44 |
Study |
1 day |
45 |
Study |
2 days |
46 |
Study |
7 days |
47 |
Study |
14 days |
48 |
Study |
42 days |
49 |
Study |
5 min |
50 |
Study |
1 day |
51 |
Study |
2 days |
52 |
Study |
7 days |
53 |
Study |
14 days |
54 |
Study |
42 days |
55 |
Study |
5 min |
56 |
Study |
1 day |
57 |
Study |
2 days |
58 |
Study |
7 days |
59 |
Study |
14 days |
60 |
Study |
42 days |
Session 1:
Session 2:
Session 3:
Session 4:
Session 5:
Session 6:
Total time to complete: 3 min for consent and instructions + Session 1 (18 min) + Session 2 (1 min) + Session 3 (1 min) + Session 4 (1 min) + Session 5 (1 min) + Session 6 (1 min) = 26 min.
Subjects: 100 web-based lottery subjects.
Expected Results:
1. Main effect for trial, such that tested items remembered better than studied items.
2. Main effect for retention interval, such that proportion of items remembered decreases with longer RI’s
3. If intervening tests attenuate forgetting, then the proportion of items forgotten across the four RI’s should be lower for tested items relative to studied items.